> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.grandviewindependent.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Richmond approves police drones and cameras, puts license plate readers on hold
- URL: https://www.grandviewindependent.com/richmond-approves-police-drones-and-cameras-puts-license-plate-readers-on-hold/
- Published: 2026-10-07T16:04:26.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-07T16:04:26.000Z
- Author: Soren Hemmila
- Tags: City Council Updates

Richmond police got most of what they asked for Tuesday night. They didn't get the license plate readers.

With minutes left before its 11 p.m. deadline, the Richmond City Council voted 5-2 to approve a new contract with Axon for police drones and surveillance cameras, along with a separate deal for Verkada security cameras at city buildings, parks, and the Port of Richmond. The council stripped out the license plate readers, cut the contract price to match, and sent that part back for more negotiation and a future vote. Councilmember Sue Wilson and Mayor Eduardo Martinez voted no.

It was the third time the contract had appeared on the agenda and the second meeting where the council debated it. The city's Flock cameras, which the council voted 4-3 in March to keep through the end of the year, go dark December 31.

[Richmond council votes to reinstate Flock Safety license plate readersThe Richmond City Council voted Tuesday night to extend the city’s contract with Flock Safety through December 31, 2026, reinstating the company’s automated license plate reader system that had been disabled since November amid a data sharing scandal, while directing the city attorney to negotiate stronger data protections![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/53/c7/53c7637d-655b-417c-b207-9b692de9e67f/content/images/icon/logo2--3--8cc3b9c0-f2ff-49fd-be0e-e0eed9aeac5e.png)Grandview IndependentSoren Hemmila![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/53/c7/53c7637d-655b-417c-b207-9b692de9e67f/content/images/thumbnail/flock-richmond-city-council-meeting-c7bae75a-4730-404d-a1ee-6efa0f773744.webp)](https://www.grandviewindependent.com/richmond-council-votes-to-reinstate-flock-safety-license-plate-readers/)

Before the council took up the contract, it heard from Sarah Hamid, director of strategic campaigns at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital rights group. Councilmembers had asked for the presentation in September. Hamid said changing vendors wouldn't change the risks.

"None of these harms depends on which vendor operates the system, and that's really important to keep in mind," she said. "An alert is a lead. It's not proof of identity, and it's not probable cause." 

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/53/c7/53c7637d-655b-417c-b207-9b692de9e67f/content/images/2026/10/sarah-hamid-eff-richmond-city-council-2026-10-06-1.webp)

Sarah Hamid, director of strategic campaigns at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, presents on license plate reader technology to the Richmond City Council on Tuesday, October 6, 2026.

Hamid said partial search records from Richmond's Flock system showed outside agencies ran roughly 2.4 million searches that included Richmond's network, compared with about 89,000 by Richmond police. Councilmember Claudia Jiménez, who requested the presentation jointly with Vice Mayor Doria Robinson and Wilson, asked how often outside agencies had searched Richmond's data, citing concerns about immigration enforcement.

Police Chief Tim Simmons said the records showed Richmond's data was open to those searches, not that anyone used it.

"I agree they were accessible, and that's what caused me to turn it off," Simmons said. "I didn't want that at all."

Simmons described what Axon would provide. He said it would replace the city's 110 Flock license plate readers camera for camera, and the city would own the equipment instead of leasing it. Sharing data with outside agencies would take deliberate action by an administrator. Six new drone docks would extend coverage to Hilltop, Carriage Hills and Point Richmond. The city's one current drone covers about 60 to 70 percent of the city.

Simmons didn't promise the readers would cut crime.

"I would not stand here and say that ALPR is going to reduce crime," he said. "It is a tool and a resource that gives us leads where there perhaps would otherwise be no lead."

Seventeen people spoke in person and four online, most of them against the license plate readers. Andrew Melendez said 14 local groups had signed a joint letter opposing the contract and more than 250 people had signed a petition. Mike Katz-Lacabe of Oakland Privacy described cases elsewhere where bad plate reads led to wrongful arrests, including a woman who spent 13 days in jail.

"It doesn't just impact criminals. It impacts the rest of us who are innocent," Katz-Lacabe said.

Ben Therriault, president of the Richmond Police Officers Association, called opponents "paid activists."

"We use technology to solve crimes," Therriault said. "Just adding more detectives doesn't work."

Robinson questioned Simmons about staffing. Simmons said the department has 13 detectives, with one out on long-term injury. Four handle felony crimes like burglaries, robberies, and car thefts for the entire city. Three handle homicides and shootings. Robinson said her district alone had 90 stolen cars and 12 sexual assaults over a few months this year.

She credited Simmons for returning with an alternative to Flock but said she wasn't ready to vote on the readers.

"You definitely followed through on the things that we asked you to do, and I appreciate that," Robinson said. "I personally think that there's enough concern in the room for us to take the time to actually look at the data to make an informed decision."

She wanted the council to see a $20,000 Police Strategies study of how Richmond has used license plate readers. The council never got to it. The study was pulled from the consent calendar and was still waiting when the meeting ended.

Councilmember Soheila Bana wanted outside experts to review the draft contract before the city signed it. City Attorney Shannon Moore said draft contracts are exempt from public records law, but the final version would be public once it went on a council agenda. Bana moved to approve everything except the license plate readers and bring that piece back for a final vote.

Councilmember Cesar Zepeda wanted to keep the whole contract moving. His substitute motion would have approved everything, including the readers, with the option to back out after the study came in. He said contract talks take about 60 days, and the city is running out of time before Flock shuts off. His motion failed 2-5, with only Zepeda and Councilmember Jamelia Brown voting yes.

Wilson didn't want the city negotiating a license plate reader contract at all until the council had seen the data.

"It's like you either approve a contract, or you don't," Wilson said. "If we don't approve the ALPR contract tonight, we could come back and approve it in three weeks if people get the answers to the questions they want."

Brown wanted a date so the readers wouldn't keep sliding from meeting to meeting. Bana suggested late October. Martinez said, "We'll try."

The rest of the agenda didn't get that far. The council adjourned without hearing the Bay Area Air District's preliminary health study of the Chevron refinery, a request for quick safety fixes on 23rd Street, the veterans housing project on Carlson Boulevard, the Keller Beach sewer study, or the city's blue curb parking program.

[****YOU GET MORE WITH A PAID SUBSCRIPTION**](https://www.grandviewindependent.com/#/portal/signup/6387e9f831b2f10031d27adc/monthly)

Your subscription enables **Grandview Independent* to deliver more:

- More time devoted to in-depth reporting
- Longer, more comprehensive stories
- Greater coverage of what matters to our community

****Quality journalism costs money.** Subscriptions allow us to keep reporting the stories that matter, without paywalls getting in the way of critical community information.

[****CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE**](https://www.grandviewindependent.com/#/portal/signup/6387e9f831b2f10031d27adc/monthly) **\- Starting at just $10/month**

****FOLLOW US FOR BREAKING NEWS:**  
• **Twitter:** [@GrandviewIndy](https://x.com/GrandviewIndy?ref=grandviewindependent.com)  
• **Instagram:**[ @GrandviewIndependent](https://instagram.com/grandviewindependent?ref=grandviewindependent.com)  
• **Facebook:** [@Grandview Independent](https://www.facebook.com/people/Grandview-Independent/61574982556947/)